HOWTO: Opportunistic IPsec

Opportunistic IPsec

The term Opportunistic IPsec is used to describe IPsec deployments that cover a large number of hosts using a single simple configuration on all hosts. Adding hosts do not require reconfiguration of all existing hosts. This concept can be used in an Enterprise or Cloud model, but can also be applied to the Internet at large. To use Opportunistic IPsec at an internet scale, see HOWTO: Opportunistic IPsec using LetsEncrypt. This HOWTO describes the Enterprise or Cloud deployment, sometimes also called Mesh Encryption"

How it works

Libreswan defines Opportunistic Groups that specify if network ranges MUST, SHOULD, MAY or MUST NOT be encrypted. When a host within such a group wants to communicate to another host in the group, libreswan attempts to setup an IPsec tunnel.

Triggers

There are two main triggers for this:

• DNS based triggers

This mode intercepts the application's DNS lookup, attempts to setup a tunnel, and then releases the DNS answer to the application. This mode is currently being developed for the 3.20 release.

• Packet based triggers

This mode installs packet based policies into the kernel. When a host wants to send a packet to another host in the group, the kernel will notify libreswan to attempt to negotiate a tunnel. Once the tunnel is established, the traffic for the target host is allowed to go out encrypted. If the tunnel fails, the traffic will either be blocked or is allowed to pass in the clear, depending on the policy for the target host.

Authentication

Any regular IKEv2 authentication method can be used for Opportunistic IPsec, as these connections are regular libreswan configurations, except for the right=%opportunisticgroup entry that defines the connection for Opportunistic IPsec. A common authentication method it for hosts to authenticate each other based on X.509 certificates using a commonly shared Certificate Authority. That is the method this HOWTO will use, as cloud deployments usually already roll out certificates for each node in the cloud.

PreSharedKey (PSK) authentication is possible, but not recommended as one compromised host would result in group PSK secret being compromised as well. Although a NULL Authentication based authentication method can be used to deploy encryption between nodes even without authentication. This mode still protects against passive attackers.

Opportunistic connections

There are currently five built-in connection groups that are defined for different policies. Each of these has a connection ("conn") entry in ipsec.conf and a file in /etc/ipsec.d/policies/ that lists the members in this group.

• conn private

Hosts in this group can only communicate encrypted and no cleartext is allowed. If the tunnel fails to establish, traffic is dropped

• conn private-or-clear

Hosts in this group will attempt to communicate encrypted, but will allow cleartext if the other end does not support IPsec. During the tunnel negotiation, traffic can be helt or passed in cleartext.

• conn clear-or-private

Hosts in this group not attempt to initiate IPsec for encrypted communication, but will accept incoming requests.

• conn clear

Hosts in this group will never initiate or accept IPsec and only communicate in the clear.

• conn block

Hosts in this group are completely blocked. It is similar to using a firewall rule to drop all traffic. This group is a legacy group and usually not in use.

At the moment, these connection names MUST be used. Future versions of libreswan will allow custom group names.

NAT

NAT is supported, but there is a catch. Pre-NAT IP's cannot be trusted. For example, imagine a cloud that uses 8.8.8.0/24 and has a client on 8.8.8.8. If this client would setup an Opportunistic IPsec connection, it would present itself as 8.8.8.8 (The IP address of Google DNS). The responding IPsec server would build up a tunnel to this client using 8.8.8.8. If it had been configured to use Google DNS, this client would now start receiving all of the server's Google DNS traffic. For that reason, if an incoming client is detected to be behind NAT, the server assigns the client an IP address from its pool. The client will map this IP address inside its IPsec subsystem so that it does not need to configure the given IP address on a real interface. It also allows the client to connect to multiple servers and receiving the same IP address without causing a conflict.

Configurations in this HOWTO assume that no NAT exists between the nodes of the cloud.

Example configuration

Below is a documented example configuration.

installing certificate

It assumes all nodes in the cloud have PKCS#12 certificate file. It assumes the "friendly name" or "nick name" of the certificate is the full hostname (fqdn) If your certificate system did not supply a PKCS#12 certificate file, but seperate files for the key, certificate and CA certificate, you can use the following command to create a PKCS#12 file:

openssl pkcs12 -export -in cert.pem -inkey privkey.pem -out yourhostname.p12 -name yourhostname -CAfile chain.pem -certfile chain.pem 

Such a file contains the host certificate and the CA certificate. To import the PKCS#12 certificate into libreswan, run:

ipsec import file.p12

Configuration

When using certificates, there is no need to change anything in the /etc/ipsec.secrets file, as that file is only used for PSK's and XAUTH.

The basic /etc/ipsec.conf does not need anything special, and it usually just points to further include files.

# /etc/ipsec.conf

config setup
	protostack=netkey
	#plutodebug="all"
	logfile=/var/log/pluto.log

include /etc/ipsec.d/*.conf

Next, we will put our Opportunistic connections in one file:

# /etc/ipsec.d/oe-certificate.conf

conn private-or-clear
        # Prefer IPsec, allow cleartext 
        rightrsasigkey=%cert
        rightauth=rsasig
        right=%opportunisticgroup
        rightca=%same
        left=%defaultroute
        leftcert=yourhostname
        leftid=%fromcert
        narrowing=yes
        type=tunnel
        ikev2=insist
        auto=ondemand
        # tune remaining options to taste - fail fast to prevent packet loss to the app
        negotiationshunt=drop
        failureshunt=passthrough
        keyingtries=1
        retransmit-timeout=3s
        auto=ondemand

conn private
        # IPsec mandatory
        rightrsasigkey=%cert
        rightauth=rsasig
        right=%opportunisticgroup
        rightca=%same
        left=%defaultroute
        leftcert=yourhostname
        leftid=%fromcert
        narrowing=yes
        type=tunnel
        ikev2=insist
        auto=ondemand
        # tune remaining options to taste - fail fast to prevent packet loss to the app
        negotiationshunt=hold
        failureshunt=drop
        # 0 means infinite tries
        keyingtries=0
        retransmit-timeout=3s
        auto=ondemand

conn clear-or-private
        # Prefer cleartext, allow cleartext 
        rightrsasigkey=%cert
        rightauth=rsasig
        right=%opportunisticgroup
        rightca=%same
        left=%defaultroute
        leftcert=yourhostname
        leftid=%fromcert
        narrowing=yes
        type=tunnel
        ikev2=insist
        auto=ondemand
        # tune remaining options to taste - fail fast to prevent packet loss to the app
        negotiationshunt=drop
        failureshunt=passthrough
        keyingtries=1
        retransmit-timeout=3s
        auto=add

conn clear
        type=passthrough
        # temp workaround
        #authby=never
        left=%defaultroute
        right=%group
        auto=ondemand
conn block
        type=reject
        # temp workaround
        #authby=never
        left=%defaultroute
        right=%group
        auto=ondemand

Assign networks

To put a host or subnet into one of the above conn groups, simple add these in CIDR notation into the policy files in /etc/ipsec.d/policies/

# /etc/ipsec.d/policies/private-or-clear
# Try IPsec and allow fallback to clear for these:
10.0.0.0/8
192.168.0.0/16
1.2.3.4/32

# /etc/ipsec.d/policies/private
# These are known hosts to support IPsec and so we insist on encryption
10.1.2.0/24
10.1.3.0/24
192.168.1.1/32

# /etc/ipsec.d/policies/clear
# default to cleartext
0.0.0.0/0

Testing & Debugging

To test, simple generate network traffic. A ping command will work fine.

You can see all the IPsec tunnels that are up using:

ipsec whack --trafficstatus

Inactive tunnels are torn down (once an hour)

You can see all the hosts that did not result in an IPsec tunnel:

ipsec whack --shuntstatus

Shunts are cleaned up regularly (once every 15 minutes)

To get a full debug status output, run:

ipsec status

To see the kernel state, you can run the following commands:

ip xfrm policy
ip xfrm state

Security Implications

Currently, with libreswan-3.19 and using packet based triggers, there is no additional check that the certificate identity of the remote host matches the identity of the host at the target IP. This means one compromised host in the cloud can take over an IP of another host and receive its encrypted traffic, that it will be able to decrypt.

libreswan-3.20 will add a DNS lookup, that can be protected with DNSSEC, to confirm the hostname in DNS for the given IP matches the certificate ID presented during IPsec negotiation.